Quote:
Originally Posted by bcbrown
[You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]
Ah, I was mistakenly looking at the last column on the Lucy chart, but that's level 65 not 60. Now it makes sense. I agree with you that this is the right approach for getting ballpark ideas on comparing weapons.
It's been a few months since that discussion, so I'm revisiting your analysis and data and it looks like it's flawed from the very start. I'm using this post for the raw data: https://www.project1999.com/forums/s...&postcount=402, where you say:
Given the data in the spoiler tags, I think you messed up the basic counts. For IFS on giants I get the same damage figures, but I count 123 punches and 183 crushes, not 207 and 297. Similarly on the 1h parse, I also calculate 16712 total damage, but 469 punches and 213 crushes, not 730 and 305.
Could you recheck your figures? |
I didn't include the misses in the logs to make it easier for people to double check the damage numbers. This is why I said "swings" instead of hits. My numbers include the misses.
I would advise you look at the post as a whole first, instead of fixating on trying to disprove specific details like this. You tend to do that a lot, and miss the forest for the trees. I don't mind constructive critisism, it helps hone my argument. But you have a bias towards me that tends to cloud your ability to read my posts, and it just wastes everybody's time.