ninja looting does not mean you make the rules

[Ledzepp02]

Originally Posted by soup [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Let me know if I understand this correctly:
Item drops, everyone rolls, he does a joke roll at first (which while stupid, in no way is is forfeiting their right to a roll, or did you specify that at the start, incorrect rolls are a forfeit?) and so then a minute later, he rolls the highest roll, but you yourself decided too much time had passed and he was no longer eligible?

That's all that matters. Whether he was a good or bad tank is beyond irrelevant (unless of course the loot rules you laid out beforehand specified performance based loot awards)?

He rolled over 10 minutes later, outside of group, when the cleric told me to get a replacement or boot him because he was just sitting in the corner ninja afk'ing or not doing anything when we had 3+ mobs in camp.