Who is really wrong

[Defo]

I don't think Highkeep is considered an "outdoor" zone like the typical outdoor zones. The outdoor zone classification applies to zones with mostly roamers that are on 6m or 6m40s respawns. Highkeep guards are 18m respawns.

I think this is a fact that veteran players feign ignorance towards. If the zone simply being outdoors, meaning you are able to cast SoW and Harmony: Then Karnor's Castle, City of Mist, Unrest and Mistmoore are all outdoor zones. But we all agree that they are dungeons. You can't cherry pick where to apply this logic.

If you extend the logic of the "outdoor" classification of the guards to the goblins, then by that logic: people can claim individual spawns down at the goblins, and there would be no camp distinctions.

However, there are camp distinctions in the goblin area. There is the raider room, the warrior room, the main floor and the side room. Each spawn is not individual. They are based on line of sight.

That being said: I don't think there are many spots where more than 1-2 guards are in Line of Sight of each other.