What guild has the worst reputation on the server?

[Fire Beetle]

Originally Posted by Legday [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

App Asgard today; penis.

fixed.

[Expediency]

Originally Posted by Kekephee [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Imagine how fun it would be to have to deal with that guy's irrepressible comic genius while your guild and two others are (after several failed attempts) killing mobs that ultimately drop two pieces of loot, to be split between three guilds. And you hope this time your guild is one of the two that will get a piece- and maybe, just maybe, out of everyone in your guild, that one item will go to you! \

OP is definitely bad and getting worse. Cant believe he thought this was good content.

Your argument about loot distribution is dumb though, if three guilds bring fifteen people, and one guild brings 45, you still have the same odds of getting the loot over time in a DKP system. If you're in a loot council you probably never had a chance at that loot to begin with.

[Kekephee]

Originally Posted by Expediency [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Your argument about loot distribution is dumb though, if three guilds bring fifteen people, and one guild brings 45, you still have the same odds of getting the loot over time in a DKP system. If you're in a loot council you probably never had a chance at that loot to begin with.

I mean, if you're the number 1 dkp guy in Asgard, and you're at the Statue raid for a breastplate, and the roll lands on Forsaken getting the breastplate, that's kind of a fuck you. The Forsaken guy who's getting the breastplate may have half the dkp you have. Right?


Taken is 1-40, Forsaken is 41-53, Asgard is 54-86. Asgard has 32, Forsaken has 12, Taken has 40. Roll comes out 44. Asgard gets the bp, right? Is that really "as far" as dkp or as the officers taking ten minutes arguing with each other over who gets the bp based on attendance, class, and whether it's a significant upgrade for the individuals being considered or just a minor one?

[Kekephee]

"as fair"**

[Spyder73]

Ok look, there is a lot of hate for this thread, but the fact of the matter is they cant all be home runs. I know I have set the bar extremely high, perhaps too high, for some of you retards to make your own threads. So f#ck you

and f#ck you especially Kekephee

[Kekephee]

Also, Forsaken* gets the bp, fuck I wish there was an edit button in RnF

[Spyder73]

Originally Posted by Kekephee [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

I mean, if you're the number 1 dkp guy in Asgard, and you're at the Statue raid for a breastplate, and the roll lands on Forsaken getting the breastplate, that's kind of a fuck you. The Forsaken guy who's getting the breastplate may have half the dkp you have. Right?


Taken is 1-40, Forsaken is 41-53, Asgard is 54-86. Asgard has 32, Forsaken has 12, Taken has 40. Roll comes out 44. Asgard gets the bp, right? Is that really "as far" as dkp or as the officers taking ten minutes arguing with each other over who gets the bp based on attendance, class, and whether it's a significant upgrade for the individuals being considered or just a minor one?

Just stop before you embarrass yourself further - The loot is flowing and thats all you need to know about how the systems works

[Kekephee]

Originally Posted by Spyder73 [You must be logged in to view images. Log in or Register.]

Just stop before you embarrass yourself further - The loot is flowing and thats all you need to know about how the systems works

You're not smart enough to dodge or spin. I asked a question and people can see you avoiding answering it.

[Kekephee]

Here's another question for Tekilya to try and squirm out of answering: If the roll is based on which guild brings more people to the raid, why is that a good thing? What's to stop one guild from just bringing 100 undergeared, underskilled players who are all a less useful class for the fight? Is a system that encourages guilds to stack the numbers by bringing 20 enchanters to a Statue fight really a great way to avoid the zerging and warm bodying that your guild accuses BDA of?

[AzzarTheGod]

Voted BDA.